| # | Team SOS #1 = hardest game vs cupcake | Record | Diff | AP | Score |
|---|
H2H = won head to head. A team that beat another one, and is within 5 points of its score, is ranked right above it (but never above a team that beat it). That's why a team can sit above one with a higher score.
Schedule profiles
Across: Schedule, how hard was your road? Up: Cupcake, how much did you pad it?Win %, did you win anyway? Every team lands in one of four profiles, or the middle band, Average Road, when its schedule is within 3/4 of a point a game of average. Tap a logo for the full breakdown. Zoom with pinch, +/−, double-click or Ctrl+scroll, then drag to move around.
Make your own version in Stats > Visualize → Swap either axis for any stat.
Who's had the toughest road
How good each team's opponents have been. Right of the middle line = tougher than an average schedule, left = easier.
Schedule strength by conference
The average Schedule score of each conference's teams. Tap one to show just that conference.
Résumé Check
We took the cupcakes away. This ranks every team on its real games only: the ones against opponents who weren't cupcakes for that team. Beating a team most top-25 teams would struggle with counts a lot; losing to a team you should beat costs a lot. Tap a team for the full breakdown.
We took the wins over bad teams away. This ranks every NFL team on its games against the top half of the league (our #1-16) only. Losses to bad teams stay in, and they hurt. SOS is the schedule rank (#1 = hardest). Tap a team for the full breakdown.
New rank = where a team lands once its cupcake wins arewins over bottom-half teams are taken away. Usual rank = our regular rankings. ▲ = moves up without them, ▼ = falls.
| New rank | Team | W-L without cupcakesW-L vs top half | Usual rank |
|---|
Cupcake Hall of Shame
Nobody schedules a cupcake in the NFL, but some schedules are a lot softer than others. Here's who has had the easiest road so far, and how they've done against the top half of the league. Tap a team for its panel.
Here's who bullies cupcakes the most, and who managed to lose to one anyway. Same cupcake rule as everywhere else on the site: an opponent far below that team's level. Tap a team for its panel.
This season's cupcake collectors
Most wins over cupcakes so far this season.
Easiest schedules so far. The number is the schedule rank (#1 = hardest, #32 = easiest).
All-time padders
| # | Team | Cupcakes | Record |
|---|
Lost to a cupcake
The ultimate shame: losing to a team far below your level. Highest-ranked teams first, then the biggest margins.
This week in cupcakes
The weekend in one page: who bullied whom, who moved, who got exposed and whose record is lying.
Bully of the Week
Biggest movers
Our ranking now vs last week. Hover or tap a line for the details.
Exposed
Record lying?
Winning records, but by how they actually play we rank them much lower. The longer the bar, the more the record is lying.
Hot takes
What we posted on X this week.
Us vs. everyone else
Our rankings next to the AP Poll, the Coaches Poll, ESPN's FPI and SP+. Consensus is the average of the four. Gap is how far we are from it: a plus means we rank a team higher than the consensus, a minus means lower. Tap any column to sort.
| Team | Ours | AP | Coaches | ESPN FPI | SP+ | Consensus | Gap |
|---|
FPI and SP+ are computer ratings, ranked here among FBS teams. Polls only rank 25 teams, so an unranked team counts as #30 in the consensus. "Ours" is always the Default ranking, no matter how your sliders are set.
Privacy
You don't need an account to use the Cupcake Index. Without one, your Pick'em picks, daily game and fantasy team stay in this browser only, and we never see them.
If you sign in
- Sign-in is handled by Google. That covers Sign in with Google and email and password accounts (Google Firebase). We never see or store your password.
- What we keep: an account ID, your first name, and your game data (Pick'em picks and record, daily game progress and stats, fantasy team), so it shows up on every device you sign in on.
- What we don't keep: no email list, no birthday, no location, no payment info. We don't sell or share anything, and there are no ads.
- Where it lives: Google Firebase. Security rules let each account read and change only its own data.
- Delete it any time: Settings (the gear) > Account > Delete my account removes everything we stored for you.
If you turn on alerts
- What we keep: the push address your phone or browser gives us for this device, the teams you follow and which alerts you picked. Nothing that says who you are.
- Where it lives: Google Firebase. Nobody can read it from the site; only our alert sender can.
- Turn it off any time: Settings > Alerts > Turn off alerts deletes it. If you block alerts in your phone's settings instead, we delete it the next time an alert can't be delivered.
The fine print
- Accounts are for people 13 and older.
- The Cupcake Index is free and just for fun. Nothing here is betting advice, and there's no real money involved.
- Questions: message us on X.
Release notes
Loading…
How it works
After each weekend the model downloads the results and rebuilds the rankings from scratch. College updates Saturday night as the games finish (with a final pass Sunday morning and another Sunday night for the new polls). The NFL updates right after Monday Night Football, with a second pass Tuesday morning for stat corrections. Each team gets a set of scores from 0 to 100, where 50 is average. The sliders decide how much each score counts.
The cupcake problem (college)
Every FCS opponent is rated like a team about 25 points worse than an average FBS team, and FCS games count only 25% as much in the power rating. Margins are capped at 24 points. Beating an FCS team 70-0 proves about as much as a close loss to an average FBS team. On top of that, the Cupcake score measures how padded a schedule is relative to the team playing it. An opponent counts as a cupcake once they are below average and at least 14 points worse than you on a neutral field, and bigger mismatches count more. FCS opponents always count. A bad team playing other bad teams isn't padding; a top-10 team scheduling them is. A higher Cupcake score counts against a team. It only counts games already played: a cupcake still on the schedule is added once the game is final.
Schedule vs. Cupcake
Schedule asks "how hard was your road?" It's the average strength of everyone you played, and it's the same no matter how good you are. Cupcake asks "how much did you pad it?" It only looks at the games far below your level. Together they give every team a schedule profile:
- GAUNTLET hard schedule, no fluff.
- BARBELL hard schedule, but padded with cupcakes too.
- GRIND easier schedule, but no padding. They played their peers.
- CUPCAKE WALK easy schedule and padded. The records to be most skeptical of.
NFL
The NFL has its own rating model, built for a 17-game league where most games are close. Four differences from college: (1) last season's rating carries over all year instead of fading out after a few weeks, because NFL rosters carry over; (2) the rating blends scoring margin with opponent-adjusted EPA per play (how well a team moves the ball and stops it, play by play), which predicts next week better than scores alone; (3) recent weeks count a bit more than September; (4) a team starting someone other than its usual quarterback is marked down. Margins are capped at 17 points and home field is worth 1 point. We tested it on every game from 2020 to 2025 using only what was known before kickoff: it picked 64.4% of winners (the old settings: 62.6%; the sportsbooks' favorite: 66.8%). Each team also gets a small coach boost: if its head coach's teams have beaten expectations in past seasons, its rating goes up a little (and down if they've fallen short). Résumé is measured against a top-8 team. Predictions refresh Thursday afternoon and Sunday morning, after the injury reports.
The NFL has no cupcakes. Nobody in the NFL schedules a cupcake, so the NFL side uses strength of schedule instead. Under each team is its schedule rank (SOS #1 = hardest so far, #32 = easiest). NFL schedule profiles cross schedule with record: Proven (hard road, winning), Easy Road (winning on an easy schedule, the records to be most skeptical of), Tough Road (hard road, losing) and No Excuses (easy road, still losing). A schedule within 3/4 of a point a game of average is Average Road: the difference is too small to call the road easy or hard, so the record mostly speaks for itself. Résumé Check takes away wins over the bottom half of the league. The NFL Bully of the Week is simply the week's biggest blowout.
Injuries
NFL injury statuses come from the league's official injury report, checked every 10 minutes. In college, the SEC, ACC, Big 12, Big Ten and MAC publish availability reports for conference games; when a team's starting quarterback is listed Out or Doubtful, its predictions are marked down 5 points, and other new absences a little each. College predictions refresh Friday evening and Saturday morning after those reports. Other conferences and non-conference games have no reports, so nothing changes for them.
Coaches
Every NFL head coach since 1999 and FBS head coach since 1980 has a Coach score from 0 to 100 (50 = average): 35% wins over expected, 30% record against winning teams, 15% postseason wins, 10% how much better the team got after he arrived, and 10% against him for padding his record with cupcakes. The hot seat (Safe, Teetering, Hot seat) is his chance of being out after this season, learned from every past coach season. Coaching trees come from each coach's career on Wikipedia.
Early season
In the first few weeks there isn't enough data, so ratings start from a preseason guess: last year's rating scaled by returning production, plus roster talent. That guess fades to zero within a few weeks. After that it's pure on-field results.
Keeping it honest
Each week the ratings pick every game of the following week. On the Pick'em page you make your own picks for the week's games, with the model's win chance shown as a small hint, and see how you did once the games are final. The model has its own row on the Pick'em leaderboard: it picks its favorite in every game, every week, so you can see whether you're beating it.
Scores, stats and standings
Live scores, box scores, player stats, rosters and standings load straight from ESPN's public data feed in your browser. They update automatically every 30 seconds while games are in progress.